Whiskey Sour: Lemons, Sugar and 19th-Century Sailors
Three ingredients, one balance: the Whiskey Sour is the template for the whole sour family and one of the first recipes ever printed in a cocktail book.
- Era: 1862 (first printed recipe)
- Origin: United States
- Created by: Unknown
- Family: Sour
The sour’s roots are at sea: British naval sailors were issued spirits with citrus juice against scurvy, which is exactly the spirit-sour-sweet formula. The first known written Whiskey Sour recipe appears in Jerry Thomas’s 1862 Bartender’s Guide, and the earliest newspaper mention found so far is from 1870, in a local paper in Waukesha, Wisconsin. No single inventor is known: the sour was a pattern, not one person’s creation.
In the 19th century sours were often served with a splash of sparkling water or a fruit garnish; later, egg white was added for a silky foam, and the egg version is sometimes called a Boston Sour. In the 1970s and 1980s many bars switched to bottled sour mix and the drink lost its reputation, until the classic cocktail revival brought back freshly squeezed lemon.
The Whiskey Sour is on the IBA “Unforgettables” list (with egg white optional), and in the US it even has an unofficial national day on August 25. In Israel it is one of the most common bar cocktails, and as local whisky making has grown, for example at the Milk & Honey distillery in Tel Aviv, which unveiled the first Israeli single malt in 2017, it has also become possible to make it with Israeli whisky.
Bartender’s tip: with egg white, shake first without ice (a “dry shake”) to build foam, then again with ice to chill. The lemon must be squeezed the same day; bottled juice flattens the drink. A classic ratio is roughly 2 whiskey, 1 lemon and 3/4 syrup, adjusted to the whiskey you use.
Fun fact: the Pisco Sour, its Peruvian and Chilean cousin, became a national symbol disputed by both countries, each of which claims pisco itself as its own.