South Side: Gin, Mint and Three Origin Stories
Some say it was born in Chicago's Prohibition-era neighbourhoods, others in a wealthy Long Island sporting club. The printed record tells a different story.
- Era: 1916-1917 (first printed recipes)
- Origin: USA (disputed: Long Island, Chicago or New York)
- Created by: Unknown
- Family: Sour / Mojito family
The South Side has three competing origin stories. The popular one says bootleggers on Chicago's South Side during Prohibition added lemon, sugar and mint to hide the taste of rough gin. Another says the drink takes its name from the Southside Sportsmen's Club on Long Island, a fishing and hunting club for society types that served a julep-style mint drink. A third credits New York's 21 Club, a Prohibition speakeasy.
The dates complicate every story: a printed South Side recipe already appears in Hugo Ensslin's 1917 book, and a similar South Side Fizz was printed in 1916, before Prohibition and before the 21 Club opened. The Chicago version therefore looks less likely, and writer Eric Felten, who looked into it, leaned towards Long Island. The full truth is unknown.
It probably started as a long drink with soda, close to a julep or fizz, before the short version, shaken and served up, became standard. There is also a lime versus lemon debate: the 21 Club serves it with lemon, while most modern recipes use lime. It is on the IBA list.
Bartender's tip: the mint should give aroma, not bitterness. Add the leaves to the shaker with everything else and shake, without muddling them hard, then double-strain so no leaf fragments end up in the glass. A single mint leaf slapped between your palms and floated on top will release its aroma. Fun fact: lengthened with soda and served over ice, the South Side becomes very close to a Mojito, just with gin instead of rum.