Sherry Cobbler: Crushed Ice, the Straw and Dickens
Sherry, sugar and orange slices over a mountain of crushed ice. In the 19th century it was perhaps America’s most popular mixed drink, and it helped make the straw a bar staple.
- Era: 1838 (first mention)
- Origin: United States
- Created by: Unknown
- Family: Wine & punch (cobbler)
The Sherry Cobbler’s exact origin is unknown, but it appeared in the United States in the 1830s. The earliest known mention is in the 1838 diary of a Canadian traveller, Katherine Jane Ellice. It won international fame when Charles Dickens put it into Martin Chuzzlewit (1843-44), where the hero tries one in America and is amazed.
The cobbler rode on two technologies of its time: the ice trade, which brought natural ice from northern lakes into cities, and the drinking straw, which made a glass packed with crushed ice easy to drink. Jerry Thomas’s 1862 recipe uses just three ingredients: two wine glasses of sherry, a tablespoon of sugar and two or three orange slices. In 1888 bartender Harry Johnson called it “without doubt the most popular beverage in this country”, with ladies and gentlemen alike.
Its success spawned a series of cobblers: champagne, claret and whiskey versions. After Prohibition it was nearly forgotten, returning with the classic cocktail revival; today it is on the IBA “New Era” list. In Andalusia, sherry’s homeland, there is a related drink called rebujito, sherry with lemonade or lemon-lime soda.
Bartender’s tip: shake the sherry with the sugar and citrus slices to pull the oils from the peel, then strain over fresh crushed ice, not cubes. Garnish generously with seasonal fruit and mint and serve with a straw. Pairing a dry sherry such as amontillado with a slightly richer one gives depth without excess sweetness. It is relatively light, lower in alcohol than spirit-based cocktails.
Fun fact: one theory links the word “cobbler” to cobbles, the pebble-like look of the crushed ice; there are other theories, and none is proven.