MixSage · All stories · עב · EN · RU
Old Fashioned (sweetened spirit-forward)

Old Fashioned: The Cocktail Named After Itself

Before Martinis, Negronis or Mojitos, a “cocktail” meant one thing: spirit, sugar, water and bitters. The Old Fashioned is what survives of that original definition.

In 1806 a newspaper called The Balance and Columbian Repository, printed in Hudson, New York, defined the word “cocktail” as a stimulating drink of spirits of any kind, sugar, water and bitters. That is the Old Fashioned formula exactly. The name itself came later, in the 1880s, when bartenders began adding liqueurs, absinthe and vermouth to their cocktails, and traditional customers started asking for whiskey made “the old-fashioned way”.

One popular story says the drink was born at the Pendennis Club in Louisville, Kentucky, in the 1880s and travelled to the Waldorf-Astoria bar in New York. Cocktail historians doubt it, since the recipe is much older than the club; at most, Louisville and New York helped make the name famous. During Prohibition, muddled orange slices and cherries crept in, possibly to mask rough whiskey. In recent decades bars have gone back to the clean version: sugar, bitters, whiskey and a twist.

The Old Fashioned is on the IBA “Unforgettables” list, and the short tumbler is literally called an old fashioned glass. Mad Men, where Don Draper makes one again and again, put it back in the spotlight in the late 2000s. In Israel it is on nearly every cocktail bar menu, and since the Milk & Honey (M&H) whisky distillery was founded in Tel Aviv in 2012, some bars offer versions with local whisky alongside American bourbon and rye.

Bartender’s tip: an Old Fashioned is stirred, never shaken. Stir with ice until it is cold and slightly diluted, then strain over one large cube that melts slowly. The orange peel is there for its oils: express it over the glass so the aroma lands on the surface, rather than just dropping it in. A common mistake is muddling fruit at the bottom, which turns the drink into a sweet punch.

Fun fact: in Wisconsin a brandy-based Old Fashioned, often topped with soda, has been the local standard for decades, a regional tradition that still dominates supper-club menus there.

Open the recipe in the app: Old Fashioned

Sources