MixSage · All stories · עב · EN · RU
Sour

New York Sour: A Chicago-Born Sour Wearing a Hat of Wine

A regular Whiskey Sour, then a red layer of dry wine floating on top. The two-tone look is the whole story, and yet the name is misleading.

Despite the name, the usual story points to 1880s Chicago, where bartenders began floating a little red wine on a Whiskey Sour. No inventor is known. Over the years the drink appeared under different names, such as the Continental Sour or Southern Whiskey Sour, and “New York Sour” only stuck later, probably because that is where it became popular. Nobody knows for sure why.

The build is simple: rye or bourbon, lemon and sugar shaken together, then dry red wine poured slowly so it stays as a top layer. Some versions add egg white, which gives the red float a steadier base. The drink was nearly forgotten in the 20th century and came back with the classic cocktail revival of the 2000s; today it sits on the IBA “New Era” list.

Bartender’s tip: pour the wine slowly over the back of a bar spoon held right at the surface so it does not mix in. Choose a dry, fruity, medium-bodied red such as Malbec or Shiraz; a very heavy or tannic wine will bury the whiskey. In Israel, with its varied local wine industry, a local red is a natural choice, though that is a bar’s preference rather than a documented tradition.

Fun fact: when the float is right, the first sip is almost pure wine and only then the sour arrives, which is why some bartenders suggest not stirring, so the drink changes from sip to sip.

Open the recipe in the app: New York Sour

Sources