MixSage · All stories · עב · EN · RU
Manhattan family (stirred)

Manhattan: the cocktail named after a city that named a family

Whiskey, sweet vermouth and bitters, stirred not shaken: one of the oldest cocktails still ordered in almost every bar in the world.

The most famous story is probably the least true. Legend says the drink was invented at New York's Manhattan Club in 1874, at a party thrown by Jennie Jerome, Winston Churchill's mother, for Governor Samuel Tilden. Historians have debunked it: Jerome was in England at the time, about to give birth. Another account comes from bartender William Mulhall, who recalled that it was invented in the 1860s by a man named Black at a bar on Broadway. What is certain is that the first printed recipes appear in the 1880s, among them O. H. Byron's 1884 book.

The original Manhattan was usually made with American rye. During Prohibition, when American rye was hard to get, many switched to Canadian whisky, and later bourbon became a common choice. Proportions changed too: early recipes gave vermouth a larger share, while the modern Manhattan leans toward the whiskey. The IBA lists it among its Unforgettables.

The Manhattan has a famous film moment: in Some Like It Hot (1959), Marilyn Monroe's character mixes Manhattans in a hot-water bottle on an overnight train. It also fathered a whole family: the Rob Roy with Scotch, the Perfect Manhattan with half sweet and half dry vermouth, and more complex relatives such as the Remember the Maine, the Tipperary and the Vieux Carré.

Bartender's tip: stir a Manhattan, never shake it. Stirring for about 20-30 seconds with hard ice gives a clear, silky drink, while shaking adds air bubbles and cloudiness. Vermouth is wine, so an open bottle belongs in the fridge and should be replaced within a few weeks; oxidised vermouth is the most common reason for a flat Manhattan. Serve in a chilled glass with a cherry or an orange twist.

Fun fact: Manhattan is one of New York's five boroughs, but Brooklyn and the Bronx also got cocktails named after them, both far less ordered today.

Open the recipe in the app: Manhattan

Sources