Long Island Iced Tea: iced tea without a drop of tea
It looks like iced tea with lemon, but there is no tea in it at all: just five base spirits, and two American states arguing over who invented it.
- Era: 1972 (accepted version)
- Origin: Oak Beach Inn, Long Island, New York (disputed)
- Created by: Robert 'Rosebud' Butt (disputed)
- Family: Highball
One story, the more widely accepted, says Robert 'Rosebud' Butt created it in 1972 while tending bar at the Oak Beach Inn on Long Island, New York, for a bartending contest that required triple sec. Another, promoted by the tourism office of Kingsport, Tennessee, says a Prohibition-era bootlegger named Charlie Bishop came up with the idea in the 1920s, and that the name comes from a small Long Island in the Holston River. The Tennessee version has no solid independent documentation, so most cocktail historians favour the New York story.
The recipe settled on small, equal measures of vodka, gin, white rum, tequila and triple sec, with lemon, sugar and a splash of cola for the tea colour. Butt himself used a ready-made sour mix. By the 1980s it was one of the most recognisable drinks in American bars, and the IBA lists it among its Contemporary Classics.
Worth knowing: this is a very strong drink. Despite its easy taste, one glass contains as much alcohol as several standard drinks, so it should be made to exact measures, sipped slowly alongside water, and never treated like an ordinary highball.
Bartender's tip: fresh lemon instead of sour mix changes everything, and the cola is just a touch for colour, not half the glass. Build over plenty of ice in a tall glass and stir gently so the fizz survives.
Fun fact: the drink spawned a whole family of place-named iced teas, such as the Long Beach with cranberry instead of cola, none of which contain tea either.